Are you dreaming about sinking into a juicy, perfectly prepared steak? Fortunately, you don’t need to live close to a butcher shop to make your dreams come true. We’ve taken the opportunity to compare two great steak delivery companies in this review of Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks to help you decide which you’ll enjoy more.
About Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks
Omaha Steaks has one of the longest standing reputations in the business. The company has been around since the early 1900s, where it began as a family butchery. Since then, it has grown to serve customers nationwide through its online purchasing and stores. They offer an incredible range of dry-aged steaks, along with other types of meat, seafood, and sides.
Kansas City Steaks is newer to the game but only slightly. They got their start about 15 years after Omaha Steaks and also started as a family business. Today, they service customers by delivering high-quality steaks sourced from local farmers and complementary side dishes and desserts to complete your meal.
Omaha Steaks
Pros
The long-standing reputation of excellence- Great selection of steak and other meats and seafood – including bison and lamb
- Offers dry-aged steaks
- An incredible selection of side dishes and desserts
- Wine service also available
Cons
- Customer service isn’t top-notch
- Minimum order required
- Not budget-friendly
- Shipping is more costly than competitors
Kansas City Steak Company
Pros
- Good variety of meat options
- Lots of bundles and meal packages to choose from
- Grass-fed beef
- Works with local farmers
- A more budget-friendly option
Cons
- Some reviews claim meats are lacking in flavor
- Side dishes are limited to comfort food-style options
- Few selections for special dietary needs
- Predictable, flat-rate shipping
Dietary Options
Omaha Steaks
close close check check close close close close close check
Kansas City Steaks
close close check check close close close close close close
Both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks focus on providing customers with the highest-quality steaks and other types of proteins. The typical person isn’t going to shop from either of these companies if they have dietary restrictions that severely limit beef and other types of meats and seafood.
Still, both of these companies also offer complete meals, side dishes, and more. This is where paying special attention to ingredients to meet your special dietary needs becomes important.
Omaha Steaks has a wide variety of meals and side dishes. Many of their dishes do contain milk or wheat, but you’re able to quickly rule those out with this guide.
Kansas City Steaks is less forthcoming when it comes to meeting special dietary needs. Most of their proteins are suitable for those on keto or paleo plans, but their menu overall isn’t well suited for anyone with special dietary needs.
Allergen info isn’t quickly accessed on Kansas City Steaks items. You have to click on the item, then go further to select more info, where you can take a look at the ingredients. Common allergens are listed at the end of the ingredient list.
Because almost all their appetizers, sides, and desserts are rich and decadent, many of them also contain dairy, gluten, and soy. Even a side as simple as their Steak Cut Fries contains both wheat and soy.
Most of the sides and extras on the menu at Kansas City Steaks are heavy, comfort food-style dishes. They’re rich, heavy, and calorically dense – so not the best if you’re concerned about calories.
Dietary Options Winner
Omaha steaks offer more varieties of meals and sides, which also means more choices if you have food allergies or sensitivities. They also make it easy to order according to your special dietary needs by providing a colored pdf chart listing all their allergen information. Compared to Kansas City Steaks, Omaha Steaks does have a few lighter selections for those concerned about fat or calories.
Menu Variety
Omaha Steaks
check - 12
Kansas City Steaks
- 35
Often when you order from a meal delivery service, you’re looking for the convenience of saving time in the kitchen. Both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks mainly offer steaks, meats, and seafood that need to be cooked from scratch in your kitchen. In this area, the goal of these companies is quality over convenience.
Still, you’re going to find options for steaks and other types of proteins that are pre-seasoned and ready to go, with directions on how to prepare them properly. Because individual preferences vary on the proper doneness of beef, how you prepare the meat in your kitchen will affect how long it takes to prepare and the overall quality of the final dish.
Both Kansas City Steaks and Omaha Steaks offer a menu of meals, sides, and desserts. For both companies, sides and extras only need to be heated through before they’re ready to eat.
Kansas City Steaks offers about 35 different options under Sides & Extras. This includes side dishes, desserts, sauces, spices, and herbed butter. Kansas City Steaks offers what seems to be endless options for steak and meat bundles, combos, and meals. There are selections of steaks, surf & turfs, bacon “flights, and meals that include sides and desserts (although these were all sold out at the time of this review).
Omaha Steaks also offers a variety of meats, sides, desserts, and appetizers. Their menu is nicely divided between steaks, meat, chicken & pork, seafood, sides, and extras like wine and desserts. Their proteins can be ordered standalone or bundled into a package. Their selection of steaks alone is expansive.
Omaha steaks have a couple of dozen appetizers, including about 12 steak appetizers and seafood appetizers that include fresh oysters. Omaha Steaks offers a large selection of sides. Where Kansas City Steaks offers mostly comfort food style sides, Omaha Steaks includes lighter options ad soups. These might not be low-calorie friendly, but they’re a nice balance to their richer meats.
Meal Variety Winner
Omaha Steaks offers more variety, especially with dishes to complement your steak, seafood, or other meats. Kansas City Steaks did offer more bundle options, but the variety of Omaha Steaks wins hands down. Plus, they offer wine delivery to complement your meal.
Ingredients
Omaha Steaks
close close - Some Options
- Some Options
- Non-GMO
grass Organic- Grass Fed
- Wild-Caught
Kansas City Steaks
close close check close
Neither Omaha Steaks nor Kansas City Steaks would be anywhere without attention to the quality ingredients. When you’re dealing with high-quality cuts of meat, where you source your ingredients matters.
Omaha Steaks has a long-standing reputation of excellence and is one of the top purveyors of beef in the United States. They ship more than 14 million pounds of just beef every year.
They source their meats and other ingredients from farms across the United States but primarily the Nebraska areas. They are committed to using meat that is naturally grown, often grain-fed but sometimes grass-fed. Any seafood from Omaha Steaks is responsibly sourced.
Kansas City Steaks also likes to keep it local when sourcing its ingredients. They’re committed to working with local farms and stockyards in Kansas whenever possible. Not all the farms they work with are family-owned but they locally reputable for their quality. Kansas City Steaks focuses on meats that are grass-fed instead of grain-fed.
When comparing steaks side by side, Omaha Steaks cuts tend to be a bit larger and a better value for what you are paying. While a bit smaller, Kansas City Steaks seem to have better marbling throughout, which ultimately leads to a more tender cut of meat.
Ingredients Winner
Both companies do a good job of being conscientious in regards to sourcing their meats and other ingredients. Kansas City Steaks wins here because their commitment to grass-fed beef results in a final product that is more tender and flavorful.
Taste & Sample Meals
Omaha Steaks
Kansas City Steaks
One of the main differences between Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks is how they age their meat, which is going to create some differences in the taste of their steaks and other beef products.
Omaha Steaks features many dry-aged beef options. Dry aging involves exposing the meat to oxygen over a period of time and letting the natural enzymes do the work. This results in meat that is more tender and more flavorful.
Kansas City Steaks doesn’t dry-age their meat. Instead, they use “wet-aging,” which is another way of saying the package and refrigerate their meat immediately after it is processed. Depending on your personal tastes, wet-aged meat may lack flavor and complexity compared to the dry-aged beef of Omaha Steaks.
Kansas City Steaks offers sides and desserts that cater best to those who appreciate comfort foods. These dishes are rich, decadent, and a bit on the heavy side. If you want a lighter meal, you can always pair a Kansas City Steak cut of beef and side with a simple green salad of your own.
Omaha Steaks offers a bit more diversity in the flavor of their meals. Side dishes include classic comfort dishes, as well as dishes that are a little lighter, like an edamame succotash and asparagus with hollandaise sauce you can drizzle, rather than being baked in a cream-based casserole.
From a customer review standpoint, both Kansas City Steaks and Omaha Steaks are pretty consistent with the taste of their meals, delivering pretty much what you expect when you order.
Taste Winner
The fact that Omaha Steaks dry ages some of their steaks give them an automatic boost in this department. Their greater variety of side dish choices also makes them stand above for flavor options that appeal to a wider range of customers.
Pricing
Omaha Steaks
PACKAGE | MEALS | PRICE PER ITEM |
Classic Favorites | 25 | $5.20 |
Value Freezer | 21 | $8.57 |
Filet Mignon Grill Pack | 25 | $6.32 |
All Protein Pack | 25 | $6.40 |
Grilling Greats | 29 | $6.59 |
Burgers & Franks Stock-up Pack | 64 | $2.50 |
Kansas City Steaks
BOXES | PRICE PER BOX |
Classic Steak Sampler Gift Box | $189.85 |
Welcome To Kansas City Collection | $119.90 |
Classic Steak Sizzler | $149.85 |
The Essential Duo | $249.75 |
Pricing for Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks depends almost entirely on what you order. Both offer more economical choices, along with steaks that qualify as higher-end. From Kansas City Steaks, a four-count of 16 oz, bone-in ribeyes cost $139.95. From Omaha Steaks, their Private Reserve 24 oz bone-in cowboy ribeye is $374.99 for four steaks. The dry-aged ribeye from Omaha Steaks costs a bit more.
The cost of sides from both companies varies depending on what you order. Overall, Omaha Steak’s sides’ cost is less, although this could be because they have some lighter options that cost less than more complex side dishes. Both companies let you choose a quantity for the sides, but Omaha Steaks provides more flexibility in letting you order sides of only two portions.
Omaha Steaks charges slightly more for shipping than Kansas City Steaks, although they do offer free shipping on some items. Shipping with Kansas City Steaks is a flat rate of $14.99, while Omaha Steak’s shipping fees vary by a considerable amount.
Pricing Winner
Overall, Kansas City Steaks offers more pricing options to appeal to customers with budgets of all sizes. Their sides typically cost a bit more than Omaha’s Steak’s, but they more than make up for it with predictable and less expensive shipping fees.
Packaging & Recycling
Omaha Steaks
Kansas City Steaks
When dealing with something as perishable as fresh meat and seafood, packaging has to be adequate to keep the food at the proper temperature throughout the shipping process. Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks both use well-insulated coolers, dry ice, and special vacuum sealing to preserve your delivery during transit.
Omaha Steaks packages their meals in an eco-friendly, reusable cooler. It’s sturdy enough that it can be washed out and reused until you’re ready to recycle it. Meals are packed with dry ice, and all meats are vacuum-sealed to preserve freshness.
Kansas City Steaks also uses dry ice to preserve its shipments. The meals are packed in a styrofoam cooler after they are sealed in cryovac packaging and flash-frozen. Some customers report their dry ice evaporating during shipment. This is a natural occurrence, and as long as your meals are cool to the touch when delivered, they are still fresh.
Packaging Winner
Honestly, these two companies are nearly identical in their packaging process. It’s the eco-friendly cooler that lets Omaha Steaks stand out by just a bit.
Customer Service
Omaha Steaks
- Order Modification
- Auto-Shipping
Kansas City Steaks
This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text.
This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text. This is placeholder text.
Customer Service Winner
In all honestly, it’s almost impossible to choose a winner in this category. Both companies offer similar services, and both have their strong and weak points in customer service. Kansas City Steaks appears to have slightly more consistent customer service.
Winner
Omaha Steaks
In comparing Kansas City Steaks vs Omaha Steaks, each company has its strong points and offers incredible steaks, along with other types of meats, seafood, side dishes, and more. In this review, Omaha Steak wins for its variety, taste, and reputation of excellence that spans years.
Still, you’re not going to go wrong by trying either of these well-respected steak delivery companies. Consider the following when deciding which is the best option for you.
Choose Omaha Steaks if you:
- You enjoy dry-aged steak
- Are looking for a range of side dish options or dessert to compliment your meal
- Like the idea of having wine delivered along with your meal
- Are looking for high-quality steaks for a special occasion
- Don’t mind paying a bit more for higher quality
Choose Kansas City Steaks if you:
- You’re not a fan of dry-aged steak
- You like having many options of bundles and packages to choose from
- Love comfort foody style side dishes
- Want great steaks but are more budget-minded